UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE NATIONAL CREDIT UNION ADMINISTRATION BOARD
In the Matter of [redacted]
Insurance Claim
Berkshire Credit Union
Docket No. 96-012
Decision and Order
This matter comes before the National Credit Union Administration Board (Board) pursuant to 12 C.F.R. §745.202 as an administrative appeal of the determination by the Liquidating Agent of Berkshire Credit Union denying the insurance claim of [redacted], the Appellant.
Claim
The Appellant filed this appeal for funds claimed to be held in his personal account [redacted] in the amount of [redacted]. The appeal involves the following:
The credit union maintained a ledger sheet noting a balance of [redacted] in account [redacted] was able to substantiate all but [redacted] of the [redacted] balance with income tax forms from 1970 through 1994. Appellant does not have tax records for four non consecutive years during this period nor are there records for the amount on deposit prior to 1970. The ALMC' did not pay [redacted] his estimated dividends and funds on deposit for these periods. Lastly, the ALMC did not accept [redacted] checkbook stub entry to substantiate a deposit of [redacted] made in 1979.
The Asset Management Liquidation Center (ALMC) was the NCUA component responsible for, inter alia, the liquidation of federally insured credit unions at the time this appeal was filed. On October 30, 1996, the NCUA Board changed ALMC's name to Asset Management and Assistance Center (AMAC). The liquidating Agent is an NCUA employee responsible for conducting AMAC liquidation functions. The terms "ALMC", "AMAC” and "Liquidating Agent” may be used interchangeably herein.
General Background
The Berkshire Credit Union, a state chartered credit union located in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, was chartered by the Massachusetts Department of Banking on May 11, 1927. Its community charter included residents of Berkshire County, limited to not over 200 persons. The credit union received federal insurance in June 1992. The credit union was determined to be insolvent and placed into liquidation by the State of Massachusetts on March 22, 1995. The National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) was appointed Liquidating Agent.
Summary of Facts and Analysis
The Appellant provided no passbook for account [redacted]. He did provide a passbook for another credit union account showing a February 1995 transfer of [redacted] to account [redacted]. The only credit union record for account [redacted] consisted of a ledger entry dated December 1994 noting a balance of [redacted]. ALMC noted that ledger entries made by the credit union were not reliable. ALMC paid the Appellant [redacted] based on the passbook entry. ALMC did not accept the ledger as adequate evidence to substantiate further payment to [redacted]. Rather, ALMC required that the amount reflected in the ledger be separately documented by the Appellant. [redacted] was able to document all but [redacted] of the [redacted] with tax returns and 1099 forms. [redacted] submitted a checkbook stub to substantiate a [redacted] deposit he made to account [redacted] in 1979. ALMC did not accept the checkbook stub as sufficient proof to substantiate the [redacted] deposit. [redacted] estimated dividends paid in years for which he had no tax records as well as the amount in the account prior to 1970. ALMC believes [redacted] estimates are reasonable but did not pay them because their requirement for substantiation was not met.
Based on the information provided by the Appellant combined with the credit union's December 1994 ledger entry, the Board is satisfied that there is sufficient credible evidence to support Appellant's claim.
Order
For the reasons set forth above, it is ORDERED as follows:
The Board reverses the Liquidating Agent's decision to deny [redacted] claim in the amount of [redacted] and grants [redacted] appeal. The AMAC shall issue a check to [redacted] in the amount [redacted]. The Board's decision constitutes a final agency determination.
So ORDERED this 20th day of November, 1996 by the National Credit Union Administration Board.
Becky Baker
Secretary of the Board